Aubrey McCarty
Cleveland Indians (ML)
Aubrey McCarty
Birthdate:
Jan. 24, 1995 (31 y, 1 m, 9 d)
Nationality:
American
Position:
1B
Bats/Throws:
S/R
Height/Weight:
6'3"/258
Entry:
2016 Draft - Round: 6, Overall: 153, Team: New York (N) Mets
Contract:
$46.28M / 2 years (2026-2027)
ML Service Time:
6 years, 10 days

No statistics this season

Current Status
MLB Service Time 6 years, 10 days
40-man Service Time 6 years, 36 days
Time as Pro 10 years
Roster Status Active Roster
Injury Status None
Options Used - This Year 2 - No
Personality
Leadership Normal
Loyalty High
Desire for Win Very High
Greed Normal
Intelligence Normal
Work Ethic Normal
Popularity
National Very Popular
Local Very Popular
Current Contract
2026 $23.14M ($23.14M left)
2027 $23.14M
Additional Info
No-Trade No
IP / PA bonusNone
MVP Bonus$850k
All-Star Bonus$190k
Batting Con Gap Pow Eye K's
Current 13 9 20 16 7
vs R 14 10 20 17 8
vs L 12 9 19 15 7
Potential 14 10 20 18 7
Fielding C IF OF
Range 2 1
Error 9 3
Arm 2 13 2
Turn DP 5
C Ability 1
Position
First 9
Run/Bunt
Speed 8
Stealing 5
Running 11
Sac Bunt 9
Bunt for Hit 1
Pitching Stuff Movement Control
Current 1 3 1
vs R 1 3 1
vs L 1 3 1
Potential 1 3 1
Pitch Ratings Cur Pot
Fastball 2 2
Cutter 1 1
Changeup 1 1
Other Pitching
Velocity 80-83 mph
GB % 38%
Stamina 1
Hold 1
OSA Rating History
Ratings Changes
2026-03-05
Avoid Ks vs R increased from 7 to 8
2026-02-06
Local Popularity decreased from Extremely Popular to Very Popular
2026-01-10
Baserunning decreased from 12 to 11
2025-12-19
Avoid Ks Potential decreased from 8 to 7
Avoid Ks decreased from 8 to 7
Avoid Ks vs R decreased from 8 to 7
2025-12-12
Gap vs R increased from 9 to 10
Avoid Ks Potential increased from 7 to 8
Avoid Ks increased from 7 to 8
Weight increased from 257 to 258
2025-12-01
Contact decreased from 14 to 13
Gap vs R decreased from 10 to 9
2025-11-24
Gap vs R increased from 9 to 10
2025-11-14
Weight increased from 256 to 257
Local Popularity increased from Very Popular to Extremely Popular
National Popularity increased from Popular to Very Popular
2025-11-05
Gap vs R decreased from 10 to 9
2025-10-20
Gap decreased from 10 to 9
2025-09-01
Weight decreased from 257 to 256
2025-08-25
Weight decreased from 258 to 257
2025-08-04
Contact increased from 13 to 14
2025-07-28
Contact decreased from 14 to 13
2025-07-07
Contact increased from 13 to 14
Movement Potential increased from 2 to 3
Movement increased from 2 to 3
Movement vs R increased from 2 to 3
Movement vs L increased from 2 to 3
2025-05-19
Avoid Ks Potential decreased from 8 to 7
Avoid Ks decreased from 8 to 7
2025-05-12
Weight decreased from 259 to 258
2025-05-05
Avoid Ks Potential increased from 7 to 8
Avoid Ks increased from 7 to 8
2025-04-14
Avoid Ks vs R increased from 7 to 8
2025-04-05
Avoid Ks vs R decreased from 8 to 7
2025-03-09
Sac Bunt decreased from 10 to 9
2025-02-08
Power increased from 19 to 20
Eye Potential increased from 17 to 18
Avoid Ks vs R increased from 7 to 8
Movement Potential decreased from 5 to 2
Movement decreased from 5 to 2
Movement vs R decreased from 5 to 2
Movement vs L decreased from 5 to 2
Local Popularity increased from Popular to Very Popular
2024-10-19
Avoid Ks vs L increased from 6 to 7
2024-10-07
Power decreased from 20 to 19
2024-09-16
Eye decreased from 17 to 16
2024-09-09
Eye increased from 16 to 17
2024-09-02
Eye decreased from 17 to 16
2024-08-26
Weight increased from 258 to 259
2024-08-19
Eye vs L decreased from 16 to 15
2024-07-22
Outfield Error decreased from 4 to 3
2024-07-15
Weight decreased from 259 to 258
2024-07-08
Baserunning increased from 11 to 12
2024-06-10
Gap vs L decreased from 10 to 9
2024-05-13
Weight increased from 258 to 259
2024-04-07
Eye vs L increased from 15 to 16
2024-03-29
Eye vs L decreased from 16 to 15
2024-03-20
Gap vs L increased from 9 to 10
2024-03-11
Power increased from 19 to 20
Eye vs L increased from 15 to 16
Avoid Ks Potential decreased from 8 to 7
2024-02-25
Weight increased from 257 to 258
2024-02-03
Eye vs L decreased from 16 to 15
Infield Range decreased from 3 to 2
Weight increased from 256 to 257
2024-01-02
Speed decreased from 9 to 8
Control Potential decreased from 2 to 1
Control decreased from 2 to 1
Control vs R decreased from 2 to 1
Control vs L decreased from 2 to 1
Weight increased from 255 to 256
2023-12-19
Control Potential increased from 1 to 2
Control increased from 1 to 2
Control vs R increased from 1 to 2
Control vs L increased from 1 to 2
2023-11-27
1B defense decreased from 10 to 9
Weight increased from 254 to 255
2023-11-13
Weight increased from 253 to 254
2023-11-09
Contact decreased from 14 to 13
Power vs R increased from 19 to 20
Power vs L increased from 18 to 19
Avoid Ks vs L decreased from 7 to 6
2023-09-11
Contact increased from 13 to 14
Gap vs L decreased from 10 to 9
Baserunning decreased from 12 to 11
2023-07-17
Eye vs R decreased from 18 to 17
Stealing decreased from 6 to 5
Weight decreased from 254 to 253
2023-05-29
Gap vs R decreased from 11 to 10
Eye Potential decreased from 18 to 17
Eye decreased from 18 to 17
Eye vs L decreased from 17 to 16
Avoid Ks vs L increased from 6 to 7
Stealing increased from 5 to 6
Baserunning increased from 11 to 12
2023-02-26
Contact decreased from 14 to 13
Eye Potential increased from 17 to 18
Eye increased from 17 to 18
Eye vs R increased from 17 to 18
Eye vs L increased from 16 to 17
Avoid Ks vs R decreased from 8 to 7
Avoid Ks vs L decreased from 7 to 6
Movement Potential decreased from 6 to 5
Movement decreased from 6 to 5
Movement vs R decreased from 6 to 5
Movement vs L decreased from 6 to 5
Weight increased from 251 to 254
Local Popularity increased from Well Known to Popular
National Popularity increased from Well Known to Popular
2022-10-14
Gap Potential decreased from 11 to 10
Gap decreased from 11 to 10
Eye vs R decreased from 18 to 17
Avoid Ks decreased from 8 to 7
Infield Range decreased from 4 to 3
1B defense decreased from 11 to 10
Movement Potential increased from 5 to 6
Movement increased from 5 to 6
Movement vs R increased from 5 to 6
Movement vs L increased from 5 to 6
Weight increased from 249 to 251
2022-07-31
Contact vs L decreased from 13 to 12
Eye vs R increased from 17 to 18
2022-05-29
Contact vs L increased from 12 to 13
Power Potential increased from 17 to 20
Power increased from 17 to 19
Power vs R increased from 17 to 19
Power vs L increased from 16 to 18
Eye vs R decreased from 18 to 17
Avoid Ks Potential decreased from 9 to 8
Avoid Ks decreased from 9 to 8
Avoid Ks vs R decreased from 9 to 8
Avoid Ks vs L decreased from 8 to 7
Speed decreased from 10 to 9
Baserunning decreased from 12 to 11
Infield Range decreased from 5 to 4
Outfield Arm decreased from 3 to 2
1B defense decreased from 12 to 11
Weight increased from 242 to 249
Local Popularity increased from Fair to Well Known
National Popularity increased from Fair to Well Known
2021-04-10
Speed decreased from 11 to 10
Weight increased from 241 to 242

Career Major League Stats

Team Year Age G PA AB H 2B 3B HR RBI R BB K SB CS AVG OBP OPS BABIP wOBA wRC+ WAR
PIT - MLB
2025 30 162 675 591 156 17 1 40 80 84 77 174 3 0 0.264 0.354 0.853 0.3069 0.365 135 2.42
PIT - MLB
2024 29 161 699 585 154 13 1 45 111 100 107 170 3 1 0.263 0.379 0.899 0.2922 0.385 145 4.60
PIT - MLB
2023 28 162 728 607 164 20 1 40 122 106 113 185 2 4 0.270 0.386 0.890 0.3212 0.387 147 4.93
PIT - MLB
2022 27 160 709 584 163 19 3 41 115 104 115 144 0 4 0.279 0.402 0.935 0.3035 0.408 163 5.78
NYN - MLB
2021 26 81 212 172 47 4 0 11 29 33 34 45 0 0 0.273 0.398 0.887 0.3051 0.387 149 1.90
PIT - MLB
2021 26 68 238 189 45 5 1 7 26 33 47 43 0 0 0.238 0.390 0.776 0.2734 0.351 124 0.54
NYN - MLB
2020 25 94 167 140 37 4 0 10 26 27 23 34 0 0 0.264 0.370 0.877 0.2784 0.378 143 1.31
NYN - MLB
2019 24 15 15 15 3 1 0 0 1 0 0 4 0 0 0.200 0.200 0.467 0.2727 0.204 19 -0.07
New York (N) (3 yrs)
NYN (3 yrs)
190 394 327 87 9 0 21 56 60 57 83 0 0 0.266 0.379 0.865 0.2920 0.376 141 3.14
Pittsburgh (5 yrs)
PIT (5 yrs)
713 3049 2556 682 74 7 173 454 427 459 716 8 9 0.267 0.381 0.886 0.3033 0.384 146 18.27
Total - MLB
MLB
903 3443 2883 769 83 7 194 510 487 516 799 8 9 0.267 0.381 0.883 0.3020 0.383 145 21.41

Career Minor League Stats

Team Year Age G PA AB H 2B 3B HR RBI R BB K SB CS AVG OBP OPS BABIP wOBA wRC+ WAR
Las Vegas - PCL
LVG - PCL
2020 25 30 126 100 30 4 1 6 23 23 24 23 0 0 0.300 0.437 0.977 0.3333 0.424 158 1.17
Las Vegas - PCL
LVG - PCL
2019 24 63 287 243 69 10 2 9 40 42 38 53 0 0 0.284 0.383 0.836 0.3261 0.366 116 1.35
BIN - EL
2019 24 56 243 200 65 10 1 14 46 35 42 34 0 0 0.325 0.444 1.039 0.3355 0.457 178 2.93
St. Lucie - FSL
SLC - FSL
2019 24 10 46 38 15 3 0 1 7 4 8 4 0 1 0.395 0.500 1.053 0.4242 0.477 203 0.66
St. Lucie - FSL
SLC - FSL
2018 23 136 609 534 181 35 7 23 86 100 63 108 4 5 0.339 0.414 0.974 0.3882 0.425 163 6.12
Brooklyn - NYP
BRO - NYP
2017 22 39 182 149 53 11 1 6 31 36 32 35 2 0 0.356 0.473 1.036 0.4352 0.465 182 2.33
PSL - GCL
2017 22 26 131 97 34 13 1 3 20 26 33 19 6 2 0.351 0.519 1.117 0.4133 0.487 209 1.96
PSL - GCL
2016 21 60 271 219 71 15 2 15 65 52 40 56 1 0 0.324 0.430 1.047 0.3709 0.441 159 2.38
Total - AAA
AAA
93 413 343 99 14 3 15 63 65 62 76 0 0 0.289 0.400 0.878 0.3281 0.384 129 2.52
Total - AA
AA
56 243 200 65 10 1 14 46 35 42 34 0 0 0.325 0.444 1.039 0.3355 0.457 178 2.93
Total - A
A
146 655 572 196 38 7 24 93 104 71 112 4 6 0.343 0.420 0.979 0.3909 0.428 166 6.78
Total - S A
S A
39 182 149 53 11 1 6 31 36 32 35 2 0 0.356 0.473 1.036 0.4352 0.465 182 2.33
Total - R
R
86 402 316 105 28 3 18 85 78 73 75 7 2 0.332 0.460 1.070 0.3850 0.456 175 4.33

Career Fielding Stats

Team Year Pos G IP PO A E Fld % RF Eff ZR
PIT - MLB
2025 1B 160 1444.0 1302 58 13 0.991 8.477 0.888 -14.37
PIT - MLB
2024 1B 160 1441.1 1293 104 11 0.992 8.723 0.984 -3.10
PIT - MLB
2023 1B 162 1467.1 1274 76 6 0.996 8.280 0.982 -3.22
PIT - MLB
2022 1B 160 1465.0 1280 106 12 0.991 8.515 0.965 -7.41
NYN - MLB
2021 1B 34 297.1 290 22 1 0.997 9.444 1.044 1.88
PIT - MLB
2021 1B 2 15.1 9 1 1 0.909 5.870 0.821 -0.42
PIT - MLB
2021 2B 1 1.0 1 0 0 1.000 9.000 0.000 0.00
NYN - MLB
2021 3B 1 1.0 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00
PIT - MLB
2021 3B 47 405.0 27 64 10 0.901 2.022 0.858 -7.87
NYN - MLB
2021 SS 1 1.0 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00
PIT - MLB
2021 LF 4 12.0 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 -0.004 -0.74
PIT - MLB
2021 CF 2 2.0 2 0 0 1.000 9.000 0.682 -0.71
NYN - MLB
2020 1B 21 182.0 168 14 0 1.000 9.000 1.065 1.36
NYN - MLB
2020 2B 1 2.0 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00
NYN - MLB
2020 3B 1 2.0 0 0 1 0.000 0.000 0.518 -0.54
NYN - MLB
2020 CF 1 2.0 0 0 0 0.000 0.000 0.000 0.00
Total 1B 699 6312.1 5616 381 44 -25.27
Total 2B 2 3.0 1 0 0 0.00
Total 3B 49 408.0 27 64 11 -8.41
Total SS 1 1.0 0 0 0 0.00
Total LF 4 12.0 0 0 0 -0.74
Total CF 3 4.0 2 0 0 -0.71
Date Team Players Sent Team Players Sent
July 18, 2021 New York (N) Aubrey McCarty
Austin Cousino
Mitchell Delfino
Pittsburgh Brett Phillips
César Vásquez
Player Awards
Award Year / Date Team
MVP / Batter of the Year 2018 St. Lucie (FSL)
All-Star 2025 Pittsburgh (MLB)
2018 St. Lucie (FSL)
League Champ 2024 Pittsburgh (MLB)
Batter of the Month Jun 2019 Binghamton (EL)
Jun 2018 St. Lucie (FSL)
May 2018 St. Lucie (FSL)
Player of the Week May 20, 2019 Binghamton (EL)
Jun 11, 2018 St. Lucie (FSL)
Apr 30, 2018 St. Lucie (FSL)
Apr 23, 2018 St. Lucie (FSL)
Jul 31, 2017 Brooklyn (NYP)
Jul 25, 2016 Port St. Lucie (GCL)
Hall of Fame Metrics
Metric Score
Black Ink6
Grey Ink54
Similar Players (1B)
Note: See Baseball Reference formula (primary position)
Similar Thru Age 31
Leaderboard Appearances
Year GS Rank
2022 160 7
2023 162 1
2024 160 7
2025 160 2
Year PA Rank
2022 709 6
2023 728 2
2024 699 7
Year K Rank
2023 185 5
2024 170 6
2025 174 5
Year TB Rank
2022 311 8
2024 304 9
Year HR Rank
2022 41 2
2023 40 6
2024 45 3
2025 40 8
Year RBI Rank
2022 115 2
2023 122 7
2024 111 5
Year R Rank
2022 104 7
2023 106 9
Year BB Rank
2021 81 8
2022 115 1
2023 113 1
2024 107 2
2025 77 9
Year IBB Rank
2024 15 3
Year OBP Rank
2022 0.402 5
2023 0.386 8
Year SLG Rank
2022 0.533 4
2024 0.520 10
Year ISO Rank
2022 0.253 4
2024 0.256 6
Year OPS Rank
2022 0.935 4
2024 0.899 10
Year G Rank
2022 160 7
2023 162 1
2024 161 5
2025 162 1